Verdict logo

About

What Verdict is

Verdict (verdict.autos) is a free used-car research and analysis service for private buyers. It does two things: it publishes research guides about used vehicles — reliability, best years, years to avoid, common problems, generation differences and model comparisons — and it generates an on-demand buying report for one specific car, either from a listing link or from year, make, model, mileage and asking price typed in by hand.

Verdict does not sell cars, broker finance, run advertising placements for dealers, or charge for reports. There is no account requirement and no paywall.

What a Verdict report contains

  • An overall verdict on whether the car looks like a sensible buy at that price.
  • How the asking price compares with realistic market value for the year and mileage.
  • Known reliability patterns and common problems for that model and generation.
  • Likely ownership and repair costs to expect.
  • An inspection checklist and questions to ask the seller.
  • Negotiation points supported by what the research shows.

A report is a research summary about a model and a price, not an inspection of the individual car. Verdict has never seen the vehicle. It cannot know its service history, accident history, or current mechanical condition. Always get an independent pre-purchase inspection before you buy.

Who is responsible for this content

Verdict's research guides are produced and maintained by the Verdict editorial team — the small team that operates the site. Guides are published under the Verdict name rather than under invented individual author profiles, because that is who is actually accountable for them. Verdict does not claim professional mechanic certification, industry accreditation, or any award or endorsement.

Buying reports are generated with the help of large language models, working from the vehicle details supplied and from Verdict's own research structure. That is stated plainly on the reports themselves and explained further in the research methodology.

Where the information comes from

Recall, investigation and safety-complaint information is checked against the public databases of the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Model years, engines, drivetrains and generation boundaries follow manufacturer specifications and NHTSA's vehicle product information catalogue (vPIC). Ownership patterns are described as patterns reported by owners, never as precise failure rates, and Verdict does not publish invented statistics.

What Verdict does not do

  • It does not provide vehicle history reports or VIN history records.
  • It does not inspect, test-drive, or verify the condition of any individual car.
  • It does not guarantee prices, repair costs, or that a car will be trouble-free.
  • It does not accept payment from sellers, dealers or manufacturers to change a verdict.

Contact

Corrections, questions and feedback are welcome — including "this guide is wrong about my car". Use the contact page. Corrections that hold up are applied to the guide.

Start with a car you're considering.

Get a free Verdict →